For shoppers searching for a Pet Botanics beef liver treats review, the key choice is not simply flavor: these soft training rewards vary in bag size and calories, and each listed option contains pork liver. I rank the 10 oz Beef Training Rewards first for its balance of 1.5 calories per treat and approximately 500 pieces, while the 4 oz Mini Soft & Chewy is the practical starter bag. The 20 oz Training Rewards offers the largest package, but at 3 calories per treat it makes more sense when bag size matters more than minimizing calories per reward.
Get pet supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
All three are bite-sized, soft treats intended for training, enrichment, and everyday rewards. The tradeoff worth noticing is the ingredient overlap: although the products are beef-forward, they also contain pork liver, which can rule them out for dogs avoiding pork. I compare them by calorie count, stated treat quantity, package size, and how clearly each fits a particular routine—rather than treating the biggest bag as automatically the best choice.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Best balance: The 10 oz option pairs approximately 500 treats with 1.5 calories per treat.
- Best small commitment: The 4 oz bag lists approximately 200 treats at 1.5 calories each.
- Largest package: The 20 oz option lists approximately 500 treats, but each contains 3 calories.
- Shared limitation: All three contain pork liver, despite their beef flavor descriptions.
- Training fit: Each is soft and bite-sized for repeated rewards, enrichment, or everyday treating.
| Pet Botanics Beef Training Rewards Mini Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, 10 oz |  | Best Overall | Flavor: Beef | Weight: 10 oz | Treats per bag: Approximately 500 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Pet Botanics Mini Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, 4 oz |  | Best Small Bag for Beginners | Flavor: Beef; includes pork liver | Weight: 4 oz | Treats per bag: Approximately 200 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Pet Botanics Training Rewards Soft & Chewy Beef Dog Treats, 20 oz |  | Best Large-Bag Option | Brand: Pet Botanics | Flavor: Beef | Net weight: 20 oz | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| pet botanics beef liver treats review | Flavor | Calories per treat | Weight | Treats per bag |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pet Botanics Beef Training Rew | Beef | 1.5 | 10 oz | Approximately 500 |
| Pet Botanics Mini Soft & Chewy | Beef; includes pork liver | 1.5 | 4 oz | Approximately 200 |
| Pet Botanics Training Rewards | Beef | 3 | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Pet Botanics Beef Training Rewards Mini Soft & Chewy Dog Treats, 10 oz
This is my leading pick because it brings together the most useful combination in this lineup: approximately 500 treats and 1.5 calories per piece. For someone who expects to reward a dog repeatedly during short training sessions, that balance is more practical than choosing a larger package with a higher listed calorie count. The soft, mini format also suits quick delivery without turning each reward into a substantial chew.
Compared with the 4 oz bag, this version lists roughly 300 more treats while keeping the same calorie count per piece, so it is a better fit for regular use. The 4 oz option still makes more sense if a smaller supply is the priority. Against the 20 oz bag, the 10 oz pick offers half the listed package weight while matching its approximate treat count and using half the calories per treat. That makes its role clear: a balanced everyday training choice, not the biggest bag.
The product description notes a BotaniFits botanical blend, soft texture, and no BHA or BHT. Those details may appeal to buyers comparing ingredient and format information, but they do not remove the main dietary caveat: the treats contain pork liver. I would skip this option for a dog that needs to avoid pork, and I would check the current package ingredient panel for any other specific sensitivities. Its approximate count is also not a guaranteed piece-by-piece tally.
Pros:- Approximately 500 treats per 10 oz bag
- 1.5 calories per treat for frequent reward use
- Soft, bite-sized format for training and enrichment
- Includes a botanical blend and has no BHA or BHT
Cons:- Contains pork liver, which may not suit dogs avoiding pork
- The approximate treat count is not an exact piece count
- Not the smallest package for owners wanting a short trial
Best for: Dog owners who train regularly and want approximately 500 soft rewards at 1.5 calories each.
Not ideal for: Dogs avoiding pork, or buyers who specifically want the smallest trial-size package or the largest listed bag.
- Flavor:Beef
- Weight:10 oz
- Treats per bag:Approximately 500
- Calories per treat:1.5
- Form:Soft and chewy mini treats
- Life stage and size:All life stages; all breed sizes
- Special ingredients:BotaniFits botanical blend
- Preservatives and origin:No BHA or BHT; made in the USA with US and imported ingredients
Our verdict“I rank this first for its useful combination of a roughly 500-piece yield and 1.5 calories per reward, provided pork liver suits the dog.”
Pet Botanics Mini Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, 4 oz
The 4 oz version is the easiest entry point for a buyer who does not want to start with a larger supply. It lists approximately 200 treats, each at 1.5 calories, giving it the same per-piece calorie figure as the 10 oz pick but a smaller overall quantity. That distinction matters if these are new to a dog, if training is occasional, or if the owner wants to see whether the soft format fits their routine before committing to a bigger bag.
Compared with the 10 oz option, this product gives up package capacity rather than changing the central training proposition: both are soft, bite-sized rewards with the same listed calories per piece. The 10 oz bag is the better fit for frequent sessions, while this one is easier to manage for lighter use. It also compares favorably with the 20 oz product for calorie-conscious repetition, since the 20 oz listing specifies 3 calories per treat. The 4 oz bag is not the best pick for maximizing supply, but that is precisely why it works as the smaller-bag choice.
The listing says there are no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives and notes a botanical blend. It also describes a beef-and-pork-liver recipe, so the flavor name should not be read as meaning beef is the only animal ingredient. Pork liver is the main limitation for dogs with a pork restriction or relevant sensitivity. With an approximate count and a compact quantity, buyers should also check the package label and count details rather than assuming the bag will last a set number of days.
Pros:- Smaller 4 oz package for trying the format
- Approximately 200 bite-sized treats
- 1.5 calories per treat, matching the 10 oz pick
- No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
Cons:- Contains pork liver, so it is unsuitable for some dietary restrictions
- Provides fewer treats than the 10 oz bag
- Approximate quantity may not match an exact training plan
Best for: First-time buyers, occasional trainers, or owners who want a smaller bag of 1.5-calorie soft rewards.
Not ideal for: Households training frequently and needing a larger supply, or dogs that must avoid pork liver.
- Flavor:Beef; includes pork liver
- Weight:4 oz
- Treats per bag:Approximately 200
- Calories per treat:1.5
- Form:Soft and chewy
- Life stage:All life stages
- Use:Training, enrichment, and everyday rewards
- Ingredients and origin:Botanical blend; made in the USA with US and imported ingredients
Our verdict“I recommend this as the low-commitment choice for occasional use, but frequent trainers will get a more practical supply from the 10 oz bag.”
Pet Botanics Training Rewards Soft & Chewy Beef Dog Treats, 20 oz
This 20 oz package is the choice for buyers who place package size ahead of the lowest calories per reward. The supplied listing gives it approximately 500 treats, matching the stated count of the 10 oz product, but each treat contains 3 calories rather than 1.5. A larger package therefore does not translate into more listed pieces than the 10 oz bag in the supplied details. Its appeal is the larger net weight, not a higher stated treat count.
That comparison makes this an intentionally different pick from my overall winner. The 10 oz product is more appealing when frequent repetitions and a lower calorie count per piece are priorities. The 20 oz version can suit a household that prefers a larger package and is comfortable with the listed 3 calories per treat. Compared with the 4 oz bag, it is a much bigger commitment, so I would not select it merely to try the range for the first time.
The treats are soft and bite-sized, designed for training and enrichment, and the description names botanical extracts including rosemary and chamomile. It also says there are no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives and that the product is made in the USA with US and imported ingredients. As with the other two, the formula contains pork liver. The combination of pork and a higher calorie count per piece makes this the weakest match for buyers seeking a pork-free or lowest-calorie option, even though it remains a plausible large-package choice for suitable dogs.
Pros:- Largest listed package at 20 oz
- Approximately 500 soft, bite-sized treats
- Suitable for all life stages and breed sizes
- Includes botanical extracts and no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
Cons:- 3 calories per treat, double the 1.5-calorie options
- Contains pork liver, which can rule it out for sensitive dogs
- Approximate treat count matches the 10 oz listing despite the larger net weight
Best for: Owners who prefer a 20 oz package and want soft training rewards for dogs that can have pork liver.
Not ideal for: Buyers prioritizing the lowest calories per treat, a small trial bag, or a pork-free recipe.
- Brand:Pet Botanics
- Flavor:Beef
- Net weight:20 oz
- Treat count:Approximately 500
- Calories per treat:3
- Form and suitability:Soft and chewy; all life stages and breed sizes
- Special ingredients:Botanical extracts, including rosemary and chamomile
- Origin:Made in the USA with US and imported ingredients
Our verdict“I would choose this for the larger package rather than calorie efficiency, since its listed treat count matches the 10 oz option at twice the calories per piece.”
How We Picked
I compared the three listed Pet Botanics products against the needs that matter most in a beef liver treat roundup: calories per piece, stated bag yield, package size, and format. Those details affect how easily a treat fits into a training session, how often a bag may need replacing, and how much reward a dog receives with each repetition. I gave the 10 oz bag the leading position because it combines the lower 1.5-calorie count with an approximately 500-piece yield, making it the most balanced option on the supplied information.
I also treated the ingredient caveat as a real point of comparison, not fine print. All three listings identify pork liver as an ingredient, so none is a good match for a dog that must avoid pork. The 4 oz product ranks as the small-bag pick because its approximately 200 treats make it a lower-commitment way to try the format. The 20 oz product earns the large-bag role, but its 3 calories per treat are higher than the other two. I did not infer differences in palatability or health effects from the product descriptions.
Where specifications differ in wording, I use the details supplied for that specific listing. For example, the 20 oz listing names rosemary and chamomile among its botanical extracts, while the 10 oz listing describes its BotaniFits blend as antioxidant-rich. Such ingredient descriptions do not replace checking the package label, especially if a dog has dietary sensitivities. My rankings reflect practical fit and listed facts—not hands-on testing or claims that one formula suits every dog.
| pet botanics beef liver treats review | Flavor | Treats per bag | Form | Special ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pet Botanics Beef Training Rew | Beef | Approximately 500 | Soft and chewy mini treats | BotaniFits botanical blend |
| Pet Botanics Mini Soft & Chewy | Beef; includes pork liver | Approximately 200 | Soft and chewy | — |
| Pet Botanics Training Rewards | Beef | — | — | Botanical extracts, including rosemary and chamomile |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Pet Botanics Beef Liver Treats Review
These three options share a soft, bite-sized training format, so I would make the decision by matching the bag to your routine rather than expecting a fundamentally different treat experience. The clearest distinctions are piece calories, package size, stated quantity, and the pork-liver ingredient.
Start with calories per reward
The 4 oz and 10 oz listings each specify 1.5 calories per treat, while the 20 oz listing says 3 calories. For sessions with many repetitions, that difference can add up across the rewards given, so the two 1.5-calorie choices are the more straightforward fit when keeping each reward smaller is a priority. This does not make the 20 oz treat unsuitable for every dog; it means the serving plan should account for its higher listed calories. Check the package guidance and your dog’s overall feeding routine rather than relying on treat calories alone.
Match bag size to how often you train
Choose the 4 oz bag if you train occasionally, want to try the format, or prefer a smaller quantity at home. The 10 oz bag is the balanced option for recurring sessions because it lists approximately 500 treats at 1.5 calories each. The 20 oz bag is the largest by net weight, but its supplied listing also gives approximately 500 treats, so do not assume it provides more pieces than the 10 oz version. Approximate counts can vary; use the package for the final product details.
Read the animal ingredients closely
All three are presented as beef treats, but the supplied product information also identifies pork liver. That makes the ingredient panel central for dogs avoiding pork or following a restricted diet. A beef flavor label alone does not establish that the recipe is free of other animal ingredients. If your dog has a food sensitivity, allergy, or veterinary diet, compare the current packaging with the dog’s restrictions and ask a veterinary professional when needed.
Choose the format for the job
Each option is described as soft and bite-sized, making the format suitable for quick rewards during training, enrichment activities, and everyday treating. Buyers do not need to choose between these three based on a stated texture difference; their clearest differences lie in the calorie and package details. If you need a treat with a different texture, a pork-free recipe, or a precisely specified piece size, these listings do not provide enough information to establish that they meet the requirement.
Interpret botanical claims carefully
The listings mention botanical ingredients in different ways: the 10 oz product names a BotaniFits blend, the 20 oz product specifies extracts including rosemary and chamomile, and the 4 oz description notes a botanical blend. These details can help distinguish the available product information, but they are not a substitute for reviewing a full ingredient panel. I would use the named ingredients as a label-checking prompt, especially if a dog has known sensitivities, rather than treating a botanical blend as a guarantee of a particular health effect.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Pet Botanics beef treat is the best fit for frequent training?
I would start with the 10 oz Beef Training Rewards for regular sessions because it lists approximately 500 treats at 1.5 calories each. The 4 oz bag has the same per-treat calorie figure but fewer pieces, while the 20 oz product lists the same approximate count as the 10 oz and 3 calories per reward.
Do these Pet Botanics treats contain pork?
Yes. The supplied descriptions identify pork liver in all three products. If your dog must avoid pork, do not rely on the beef flavor name to establish suitability; check the package ingredient panel and choose a product that meets the dog’s dietary needs.
How many calories are in each treat?
The 4 oz and 10 oz options list 1.5 calories per treat. The 20 oz Training Rewards listing specifies 3 calories per treat. If you give multiple rewards during a session, include them in your dog’s overall feeding plan and check the label for current information.
Which option has the most treats?
The 10 oz and 20 oz product descriptions each list approximately 500 treats, while the 4 oz bag lists approximately 200. These are approximate counts, not guaranteed exact totals. The 20 oz bag has the highest net weight, but the supplied description does not list a higher treat count than the 10 oz bag.
Are these treats appropriate for puppies and dogs of different sizes?
The supplied product details describe the options as suitable for all life stages, and the 10 oz and 20 oz listings also mention all breed sizes. The soft, bite-sized format is intended for training and rewards, but individual dietary needs vary. Check the packaging and ask a veterinarian if your puppy or dog has a health condition, sensitivity, or special feeding plan.
Conclusion
For most buyers choosing among these three, I recommend the 10 oz Pet Botanics Beef Training Rewards: its approximately 500-piece count and 1.5 calories per treat make it the most balanced pick for ongoing training. Choose the 4 oz Mini Soft & Chewy if you want a smaller supply for occasional rewards or to try the format. Select the 20 oz Training Rewards if the larger package is your priority and 3 calories per treat suit your routine. I would skip all three for a dog that must avoid pork liver, and I would verify the current ingredient label before buying for a dog with dietary sensitivities.
