For a balanced mix of festive variety and a full 24-day countdown, I’d choose the BarkBox Dog Advent Calendar, which combines 16 treats with eight toys. The MON2SUN 10.6 oz calendar stands out for households prioritizing treat quantity, while the SmartBones calendar is aimed at small dogs that prefer rawhide-free chews. The main tradeoffs are treat variety versus quantity, a treat-only countdown versus toys, and whether the calendar’s portions suit your dog. Read on for my full comparison of the best dog treat advent calendars and who each option suits.
Get pet supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
BarkBox is the lineup’s clearest mixed-gift pick: eight toys break up the treat-only routine, though dogs uninterested in toys may get less from that format.
Calendar size and day count are not the same: the Howliday 25-day calendars include an extra day, while many alternatives follow a 24-day countdown.
More listed ounces do not automatically mean better fit: MON2SUN’s 10.6 oz and Howliday’s 11 oz suit buyers focused on quantity, but treat size and daily portions still matter.
Specialized formats serve different dogs: SmartBones is intended for small dogs and emphasizes rawhide-free chews; Himalayan Dog Chew offers 12 full-size chews rather than a daily 24-piece routine.
The lineup spans very different treat styles: cookie calendars, chicken-and-fish jerky, cheese-and-bacon treats, and salmon-and-sweet-potato treats make ingredient preferences a useful first filter.
| Wüfers Singing Snow Globe Dog Advent Calendar with 24 Holiday Cookies |  | Best for a Festive Gift | Treat count: 24 cookies | Treat form: Decorated cookies | Feature: Musical | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 24-Day Christmas Dog Advent Calendar with Bone-Shaped Gingerbread Treats |  | Best for Individually Wrapped Treats | Treat count: 24 | Flavor: Gingerbread | Treat form: Mini biscuits | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Christmas Dog Treat Advent Calendar with Chicken and Fish Jerky |  | Best for Savory Reward Variety | Number of compartments: 24 | Flavor: Chicken and fish | Treat type: Jerky treats | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Advent Calendar, 25 Days of Treats, 3.5 oz (Pack of 2) |  | Best for Two-Dog Households | Calendars per pack: 2 | Treat count: 25 days per calendar | Total package weight: 7 ounces | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 2026 Christmas Dog Advent Calendar with Cheese and Bacon Treats |  | Best for Savory Biscuit Fans | Treat count: 24 | Flavor: Cheese and bacon | Treat form: Crunchy biscuits | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| JoyGnaw Dog Treats Christmas Advent Calendar, 24 Days, 6.2 oz |  | Best for Simple Chicken Treats | Brand: JoyGnaw | Treat count: 24 | Net weight: 6.2 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Trader Joe’s Advent Calendar for Dogs, Salmon and Sweet Potato Treats, 24 Days |  | Best for Soft, Limited-Ingredient Treats | Brand: Trader Joe’s | Treat count: 24 | Net weight: 5.11 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BarkBox Dog Advent Calendar with 8 Toys and 16 Treats |  | Best Treat-and-Toy Mix | Brand: BarkBox | Contents: 8 plush toys and 16 dog treats | Material: Polyester | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Advent Calendar and Christmas Treats, 11 oz |  | Best for an Extended Countdown and Cookie Stash | Brand: Howliday | Calendar length: 25 days | Calendar treat amount: 3.5 oz | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Bonne et Filou 2026 Dog Treats Advent Calendar, 24 Count |  | Best Premium Variety Assortment | Brand: Bonne et Filou | Treat count: 24 | Treat varieties: 4 macarons, 12 bone treats, 8 truffles | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SmartBones Furry Christmas Advent Calendar with Rawhide-Free Chews for Small Dogs |  | Best for Small Dogs Who Prefer Chews | Brand: SmartBones | Chew count: 24 | Varieties: 8 mini bones with sweet potato, 8 mini canes with chicken, 8 chicken-wrapped mini sticks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MON2SUN Dog Treats Christmas Advent Calendar, 24 Days, 10.6 oz |  | Best for Treat Variety | Brand: MON2SUN | Countdown: 24 days | Treat varieties: 10 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Advent Calendar, 25 Days of Treats, 3.5 oz | | Best for a 25-Day, Limited-Ingredient Countdown | Brand: Howliday | Treat count: 25 days | Net weight: 3.5 ounces | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Jungle Calling 2026 Dog Advent Calendar, 24 Days of Holiday Treats |  | Best for Meat-Loving Dogs | Brand: Jungle Calling | Countdown: 24 days | Treat varieties: Festive fun-shaped treats, freeze-dried treats, wraps, kabob meatballs, meat rolls, and sausages | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Himalayan Dog Chew Advent Calendar for Dogs, 12 Full-Size Chews |  | Best for Full-Size Chews | Brand: Himalayan Dog Chew | Contents: 12 full-size chews | Treat varieties: Churros and Yogurt Sticks | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| dog treat advent calendar | Brand | Treat count |
|---|---|---|
| Wüfers Singing Snow Globe Dog | — | 24 cookies |
| 24-Day Christmas Dog Advent Ca | — | 24 |
| Christmas Dog Treat Advent Cal | — | — |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Ad | — | 25 days per calendar |
| 2026 Christmas Dog Advent Cale | — | 24 |
| JoyGnaw Dog Treats Christmas A | JoyGnaw | 24 |
| Trader Joe’s Advent Calendar f | Trader Joe’s | 24 |
| BarkBox Dog Advent Calendar wi | BarkBox | — |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Advent Calen | Howliday | — |
| Bonne et Filou 2026 Dog Treats | Bonne et Filou | 24 |
| SmartBones Furry Christmas Adv | SmartBones | — |
| MON2SUN Dog Treats Christmas A | MON2SUN | — |
| Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Ad | Howliday | 25 days |
| Jungle Calling 2026 Dog Advent | Jungle Calling | — |
| Himalayan Dog Chew Advent Cale | Himalayan Dog Chew | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
The musical snow-globe design gives this calendar a stronger gift feel than the straightforward carton of Thoughtfully’s gingerbread biscuits. Behind the holiday presentation are 24 decorated cookies, so it suits households that want a daily countdown rather than a single special treat. The cookies use human-grade ingredients and dog-safe icing, and they are baked in North America without artificial colors or flavors. That broadens its appeal across breeds and life stages, though it does not make the cookies a daily dietary staple: they are intended as occasional snacks. Compared with the chicken-and-fish jerky calendar, this pick favors decorated-cookie presentation over varied meat treats. I’d choose it for festive display and gifting, but the missing cookie dimensions and individual ingredient details make portion and sensitivity checks harder.
Pros:- Includes 24 decorated cookies for a daily countdown
- Musical snow-globe feature adds a gift-ready presentation
- Uses human-grade ingredients and dog-safe icing
- Baked in North America without artificial colors or flavors
Cons:- Treats are intended as occasional snacks, not a regular diet staple
- Cookie dimensions and individual ingredient details are not provided
Best for: Gift shoppers who want a musical holiday display and decorated cookies for a dog of any breed size
Not ideal for: Caregivers who need detailed ingredient and treat-size information, or dogs that do best with meat-based rewards
- Treat count:24 cookies
- Treat form:Decorated cookies
- Feature:Musical
- Ingredients:Human-grade; no artificial colors or flavors
- Icing:Dog-safe
- Made in:North America
- Life stage:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Choose this calendar when festive presentation and decorated cookies matter more than detailed ingredient disclosure or savory treat variety.”
24-Day Christmas Dog Advent Calendar with Bone-Shaped Gingerbread Treats
Individual wrappers make this Thoughtfully calendar a practical choice for people who want to hand out one treat at a time or keep each biscuit separate until its day. Its 24 mini gingerbread biscuits come in four hand-decorated designs, giving the countdown more visual variety than the single-flavor cheese-and-bacon biscuit calendar. The human-grade, limited-ingredient positioning may appeal to buyers looking for a simpler treat format, though the supplied information does not name the ingredients. Mini size can work well for small rewards, but it may feel skimpy to owners expecting a substantial daily chew. The gingerbread flavor is also less universally appealing than the chicken and fish options in the jerky calendar. I’d pick this for tidy portioning and colorful presentation, not for dogs that avoid gingerbread or need larger treats.
Pros:- 24 individually wrapped biscuits support one-at-a-time serving
- Four hand-decorated designs add variety to the calendar
- Human-grade and limited-ingredient positioning
- Suitable for dogs of all breed sizes
Cons:- Mini-sized biscuits may be too small for owners seeking a substantial treat
- Gingerbread flavor may not appeal to every dog
- Specific ingredients are not listed in the supplied product details
Best for: Owners who want individually wrapped, small holiday biscuits for portioned rewards or a tidy countdown
Not ideal for: People seeking larger treats, named ingredient details, or savory meat-based options for flavor-sensitive dogs
- Treat count:24
- Flavor:Gingerbread
- Treat form:Mini biscuits
- Designs:Four hand-decorated designs
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Ingredients:Human-grade
- Container:Carton
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Pick this calendar for individually wrapped mini biscuits and decorative variety, provided your dog enjoys gingerbread.”
Christmas Dog Treat Advent Calendar with Chicken and Fish Jerky
For dogs more motivated by meat than biscuits, this calendar’s chicken and fish jerky sets it apart from Thoughtfully’s gingerbread minis and the cheese-and-bacon biscuit calendar. Its 24 compartments create a familiar daily countdown, while the 7-ounce assortment is also described as suitable for training rewards. That dual purpose can make the contents useful beyond opening one door each day. The tradeoff is less predictability: treat types and flavors vary by compartment, so it is not the clearest pick for dogs that accept only one known option. The limited-ingredient designation is helpful context, but the supplied details do not specify the full ingredient lists or the mix of varieties. I’d favor it for a dog that likes both chicken and fish and for owners who can adapt treat portions to training.
Pros:- 24 compartments provide a daily countdown
- Assorted chicken and fish treats offer savory variety
- Treats can be used as training rewards
- Limited-ingredient diet designation
Cons:- Treat varieties and flavors vary by compartment
- Full ingredient details and the assortment breakdown are not provided
- Seasonal calendar format is intended for a holiday countdown
Best for: Owners of dogs who enjoy both chicken and fish and want countdown treats that can also serve as rewards
Not ideal for: Caregivers whose dogs need one consistent flavor or who require full treat-by-treat ingredient details
- Number of compartments:24
- Flavor:Chicken and fish
- Treat type:Jerky treats
- Net weight:7 ounces
- Item form:Strip
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Life stage:All life stages
- Container:Carton
Our verdict“Choose this one for a dog that likes savory variety and can use jerky as both a holiday treat and a training reward.”
Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Advent Calendar, 25 Days of Treats, 3.5 oz (Pack of 2)
This pack stands apart from the other single-calendar options by providing two calendars, each with 25 days of crunchy treats. That makes it a natural fit for a two-dog household or for someone who wants a spare calendar, while the low-calorie claim may suit owners trying to keep holiday rewards modest. The bone-shaped treats have vanilla and honey flavor, rather than the meat-forward profile of the chicken-and-fish jerky calendar or the cheese-and-bacon biscuits. Human-grade ingredients and North American production add useful context, but the total listed weight is only 7 ounces across both calendars, so buyers should not assume large portions. Potential milk, soy, and wheat allergens are a real limitation for dogs with sensitivities. I’d choose this for shared 25-day countdowns, but check allergen suitability first.
Pros:- Pack includes two calendars with 25 days of treats each
- Low-calorie claim may suit owners limiting treat portions
- Human-grade ingredients and North American production
- Suitable for all breeds and life stages
Cons:- May contain milk, soy, and wheat
- Pack weighs 7 ounces total, so treat portions may be modest
- Vanilla and honey flavor is less suited to dogs that prefer meat treats
Best for: Households with two dogs that want matching 25-day countdowns and crunchy, low-calorie-positioned treats
Not ideal for: Dogs with milk, soy, or wheat sensitivities, or buyers seeking larger treat portions or savory flavors
- Calendars per pack:2
- Treat count:25 days per calendar
- Total package weight:7 ounces
- Weight per calendar:3.5 ounces
- Flavor:Vanilla and honey
- Treat shape:Dog bone
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Potential allergens:May contain milk, soy, and wheat
Our verdict“This pack makes the most sense for two-dog homes wanting matching 25-day calendars, as long as the listed potential allergens are suitable.”
2026 Christmas Dog Advent Calendar with Cheese and Bacon Treats
The cheese-and-bacon flavor gives this calendar a clear savory-biscuit identity, unlike the sweet gingerbread profile of Thoughtfully’s calendar or the vanilla-and-honey treats in the Howliday two-pack. It includes 24 crunchy biscuits and weighs 10 ounces, making it a straightforward choice for owners who want one familiar biscuit style rather than a changing jerky assortment. Small-batch production and ingredients sourced in the USA add appeal for buyers who value domestic sourcing, while the vintage Christmas design keeps the presentation seasonal. The tradeoff is dietary fit: cheese and bacon may not work for dogs with restrictions, and crunchy biscuits are a poor match for dogs that need soft treats. I’d select it for a dog already suited to crunchy savory biscuits, not as a flexible option for sensitive diets.
Pros:- 24 biscuits provide a daily holiday countdown
- Savory cheese-and-bacon flavor offers an alternative to sweet calendars
- Made in the USA in small batches
- Vintage Christmas calendar design
Cons:- Cheese and bacon may not suit dogs with dietary restrictions
- Crunchy biscuit texture is unsuitable for dogs needing soft treats
- The calendar offers a single listed flavor profile rather than varied treat types
Best for: Owners of dogs that enjoy crunchy savory biscuits and have no restrictions around cheese or bacon
Not ideal for: Dogs needing soft treats or those with dietary restrictions that rule out cheese or bacon
- Treat count:24
- Flavor:Cheese and bacon
- Treat form:Crunchy biscuits
- Weight:10 ounces
- Made in:USA
- Production:Small batch
- Life stage:All life stages
- Breed recommendation:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Choose this calendar for a dog that already handles crunchy cheese-and-bacon biscuits, and skip it if texture or diet restrictions are a concern.”
JoyGnaw Dog Treats Christmas Advent Calendar, 24 Days, 6.2 oz
For a straightforward 24-day countdown, JoyGnaw keeps the formula and format uncomplicated: each door holds a portioned chicken treat, and the recipe is described as grain-free, rawhide-free, and soy-free. That makes it a more focused choice than BarkBox’s calendar, which splits its contents between treats and plush toys. The all-sizes, all-life-stages positioning also gives households with more than one dog a flexible option, though portion size still matters for each dog.
The tradeoff is limited variety: every serving is chicken, so dogs that prefer different flavors—or have poultry sensitivities—are a poor match. At 6.2 ounces total, it is a small daily reward rather than a substantial chew. I’d choose it for a simple treat ritual, not for a calendar meant to supply larger snacks.
Pros:- One individually portioned treat behind each of 24 doors
- Chicken recipe described as grain-free, rawhide-free, and soy-free
- Intended for dogs of all sizes and life stages
Cons:- Single-flavor chicken format does not suit dogs with poultry sensitivities or treat variety preferences
- The 6.2-ounce total means portions are limited
- Ingredient and nutrient details beyond the listed claims are not provided
Best for: Owners seeking one portioned chicken treat per day for a dog without poultry sensitivities, especially households that value grain-free and rawhide-free ingredients.
Not ideal for: Dogs with poultry sensitivities or owners wanting varied flavors, larger chews, or a substantial total treat quantity.
- Brand:JoyGnaw
- Treat count:24
- Net weight:6.2 oz
- Flavor:Chicken
- Life stage:All life stages
- Breed size:All sizes
- Dietary features:Grain-free, rawhide-free, soy-free
- Container:Carton
Our verdict“Choose JoyGnaw for a simple chicken-based daily countdown, but skip it if your dog needs poultry-free treats or larger portions.”
Trader Joe’s Advent Calendar for Dogs, Salmon and Sweet Potato Treats, 24 Days
Trader Joe’s stands apart from JoyGnaw’s chicken-only calendar with soft salmon and sweet potato treats in a limited-ingredient, grain-free format. Its 24 perforated windows make the daily routine easy, while the stated 60% salmon and 40% sweet potato composition gives buyers a clearer picture of the two featured ingredients than some calendars provide. The soft texture may also suit dogs that find harder treats less comfortable to chew.
The catch is scale: each day’s pouch is described as petite, and the package contains 5.11 ounces of treats in total. Compared with Bonne et Filou’s much heavier assortment of 24 handmade treats, this is a lighter daily nibble, not a stash for generous rewards. It is also explicitly seasonal, so I’d pick it for a Christmas countdown rather than a year-round treat routine.
Pros:- 24 pouches provide a clear daily countdown
- Soft treats offer an alternative to harder treats such as Bonne et Filou’s
- Limited-ingredient, grain-free recipe features salmon and sweet potato
- Ingredient proportions are specified as 60% salmon and 40% sweet potato
Cons:- Treat pouches are petite
- The 5.11-ounce treat total may be modest for larger dogs or frequent treaters
- Designed specifically for a seasonal Christmas countdown
Best for: Owners who want a soft, grain-free salmon-and-sweet-potato countdown for a dog that does well with those ingredients.
Not ideal for: People seeking larger daily treats, a multi-flavor assortment, or a calendar they can use beyond the Christmas season.
- Brand:Trader Joe’s
- Treat count:24
- Net weight:5.11 oz
- Flavor:Smoked Scottish salmon and sweet potato
- Salmon content:60%
- Sweet potato content:40%
- Texture:Soft
- Dietary features:Limited ingredient, grain-free
- Life stage:All life stages
Our verdict“Pick this calendar for petite, soft salmon treats and a simple ingredient focus, not for large portions or broad flavor variety.”
BarkBox Dog Advent Calendar with 8 Toys and 16 Treats
BarkBox is the pick for buyers who want the countdown to include play, not just snacks: the calendar contains eight plush toys and 16 treats. Squeakers, crinkle textures, tug straps, and plush material give the toy doors more variety than JoyGnaw’s all-treat format, so this can stretch the holiday ritual for a dog that enjoys both food rewards and interactive toys. Its 16-by-10-inch gift-ready presentation also makes it a more substantial unboxing choice than a compact treat carton.
That mix comes with a real compromise: only 16 of the 24 items are treats, and the available details do not specify treat ingredients, nutrition, toy dimensions, or individual toy designs. Compared with Bonne et Filou’s clearly listed treat assortment, BarkBox offers less food transparency. I’d favor it for play value, but not for dogs with strict dietary needs or owners who want a treat behind every door.
Pros:- Combines eight plush toys with 16 treats
- Toy features include squeakers, crinkle textures, tug straps, and fluff
- Gift-ready Christmas presentation
- Large 16-by-10-inch format creates a more substantial countdown display
Cons:- Only 16 of the 24 items are treats
- Treat ingredients and nutritional details are not specified
- Individual toy sizes and designs are not specified
Best for: Gift-givers whose dogs enjoy plush toys as well as treats and who do not need detailed ingredient information before choosing a snack.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking 24 treat portions, dogs with dietary restrictions, or buyers who need to know toy sizes and specific designs in advance.
- Brand:BarkBox
- Contents:8 plush toys and 16 dog treats
- Material:Polyester
- Dimensions:16 x 10 inches
- Weight:3.5 pounds
- Theme:Christmas
- Toy features:Squeakers, crinkle textures, tug straps, and fluff
- Included components:Toys and treats
Our verdict“Choose BarkBox when toy variety matters as much as snacks, but select a treat-only calendar if food quantity or ingredient transparency comes first.”
Howliday 2026 Dog Advent Calendar and Christmas Treats, 11 oz
Howliday combines a 25-day calendar with an additional 11 ounces of festive cookies, making it the strongest choice here for owners who want more than a small daily reveal. Its five cookie shapes and vanilla, honey, and peppermint flavors add variety beyond JoyGnaw’s single chicken flavor, while the human-grade ingredient claim and North American production details may appeal to buyers looking for a more celebratory assortment. The extra cookies also give the household treats to share after the calendar countdown ends.
Unlike Trader Joe’s soft, limited-ingredient salmon treats, Howliday may contain milk, soy, and wheat, so it is a less suitable fit for dogs avoiding those ingredients. The calendar portion itself is only 3.5 ounces; most of the listed 11 ounces comes from the separate cookie assortment. I’d choose it for variety and extra cookies, not for a large amount of calendar treats.
Pros:- 25-day countdown runs longer than the 24-day calendars
- Includes 11 oz of additional cookies alongside the 3.5 oz calendar treats
- Cookies come in five festive shapes and three listed flavors
- Made in North America with human-grade ingredients
Cons:- May contain milk, soy, and wheat
- The advent-calendar portion is 3.5 oz; the additional cookies account for most of the stated treat amount
- Flavor and shape variety may be less useful for dogs with ingredient restrictions
Best for: Owners who want a 25-day countdown plus a separate assortment of festive cookies, and whose dogs can eat the listed potential allergens.
Not ideal for: Dogs avoiding milk, soy, or wheat, or buyers who want the calendar itself to contain most of the total treat amount.
- Brand:Howliday
- Calendar length:25 days
- Calendar treat amount:3.5 oz
- Additional cookies:11 oz
- Cookie shapes:5 festive shapes
- Flavors:Vanilla, honey, peppermint
- Ingredients:Human-grade; may contain milk, soy, and wheat
- Made in:North America
- Life stage:All life stages
Our verdict“Pick Howliday for an extended countdown and extra festive cookies if its potential milk, soy, and wheat ingredients suit your dog.”
Bonne et Filou 2026 Dog Treats Advent Calendar, 24 Count
Bonne et Filou earns its place for three distinct treat styles: four macarons, 12 bone treats, and eight truffles. That mix offers more texture and format variety than JoyGnaw’s single chicken treat or Trader Joe’s single soft-treat style, and the 2.3-pound total package makes this a much more substantial assortment on paper. The treats are described as handmade with locally sourced, human-grade ingredients and can be broken into smaller pieces, giving owners a way to adapt the harder pieces for small dogs.
The main tradeoff is texture: these are hard treats, so breaking them up may be necessary for some dogs, and color can vary between handmade batches. The listed ingredients include peanut butter, yogurt, and honey, which is a narrower fit for dogs with relevant sensitivities. I’d choose this for owners prioritizing variety and a sizable treat assortment over soft, ready-to-serve portions.
Pros:- Three treat varieties: macarons, bone treats, and truffles
- Made in the USA with locally sourced, human-grade ingredients
- Hard treats can be broken into smaller pieces for small dogs
- 2.3-pound package is substantially heavier than the smaller treat-only calendars
Cons:- Hard texture may be unsuitable without breaking treats into smaller pieces
- Handmade treats may vary in color
- Listed ingredients include peanut butter and yogurt, limiting suitability for some dogs
Best for: Owners who want a varied, substantial treat assortment and are comfortable breaking harder treats into smaller pieces for their dog.
Not ideal for: Dogs that need soft treats or owners whose dogs must avoid peanut butter, yogurt, or other listed ingredients.
- Brand:Bonne et Filou
- Treat count:24
- Treat varieties:4 macarons, 12 bone treats, 8 truffles
- Weight:2.3 pounds
- Ingredients:Peanut butter, yogurt, honey
- Ingredient claims:Human-grade, preservative-free, limited ingredient
- Made in:USA
- Suitable for:All life stages and all breed sizes
- Shelf life:12+ months
Our verdict“Choose Bonne et Filou for a varied, substantial assortment if your dog can handle hard treats and the listed ingredients.”
SmartBones Furry Christmas Advent Calendar with Rawhide-Free Chews for Small Dogs
SmartBones is the chew-focused pick in this group: its 24 doors hold three types of mini chew rather than a broad mix of snack formats. The equal split of sweet-potato mini bones, chicken mini canes, and chicken-wrapped sticks gives a small dog some variety while keeping the calendar centered on chewing. That makes it a different fit from MON2SUN’s 10 treat varieties, which ranges across biscuits, sausages, and soft chews. The rawhide-free, vitamin- and mineral-enriched recipe may suit buyers seeking an alternative to rawhide, but the feeding guidance limits use to supplemental treats and calls for supervision. With a 9.7-ounce net weight and small-dog focus, it is less suited to households seeking a larger or longer-lasting chew for a bigger dog.
Pros:- Provides 24 chews across three varieties, with eight of each type.
- Rawhide-free formula is described as easy to digest.
- Vitamin- and mineral-enriched treats offer more than one chew format.
- Chewing can help satisfy a dog’s natural urge to chew.
Cons:- Intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding, not as a meal.
- Dogs should be supervised while consuming the chews.
- Small-dog sizing may not suit larger dogs seeking more substantial chews.
Best for: Owners of small dogs who want a 24-day countdown built around rawhide-free mini chews in a few familiar formats.
Not ideal for: Owners of large dogs or anyone looking for a complete daily food; these are small supplemental chews that require supervision.
- Brand:SmartBones
- Chew count:24
- Varieties:8 mini bones with sweet potato, 8 mini canes with chicken, 8 chicken-wrapped mini sticks
- Dog size:Small
- Dietary features:Rawhide-free; vitamin- and mineral-enriched
- Net weight:9.7 ounces
- Life stage:All life stages
- Feeding guidance:Feed up to two chews per day; intermittent or supplemental feeding only; supervise consumption
Our verdict“Choose SmartBones if your small dog enjoys chewing and you want a rawhide-free countdown, but skip it if you need a complete food or treats for a larger dog.”
MON2SUN Dog Treats Christmas Advent Calendar, 24 Days, 10.6 oz
MON2SUN puts variety ahead of a single treat style, with 10 varieties spread across 24 days. Its assortment includes meatballs, soft chews, biscuits, sausages, and wrapped sticks, so it offers more changes in shape and texture than the three chew types in the SmartBones Furry Christmas calendar. That range suits owners whose dogs enjoy sampling different snacks, and the chicken, codfish, chicken liver, and beef flavors broaden the mix. The tradeoff is predictability: recipes and textures vary, so it may be harder to plan around a dog with specific preferences or dietary sensitivities. It is recommended for small adult dogs, making it a less flexible choice than Howliday’s 25-day calendar, which is listed for all life stages and breed sizes.
Pros:- Includes 10 varieties across a 24-day countdown.
- Mixes biscuits, soft chews, meatballs, sausages, and wrapped sticks.
- Offers chicken, codfish, chicken liver, and beef flavors.
- The 10.6-ounce contents provide a larger stated net weight than Howliday’s 3.5-ounce calendar.
Cons:- Recommended for small dogs, limiting its fit for larger breeds.
- Treat sizes, textures, and recipes vary across the assortment.
- Supervision and access to fresh water are advised during feeding.
Best for: Owners of small adult dogs that enjoy trying different treat shapes, textures, and meat flavors during a holiday countdown.
Not ideal for: Owners of dogs with ingredient sensitivities or strict treat preferences, since recipes, treat sizes, and textures vary.
- Brand:MON2SUN
- Countdown:24 days
- Treat varieties:10
- Flavors:Chicken, codfish, chicken liver, beef
- Treat forms:Meatballs, soft chews, biscuits, sausages, wrapped sticks
- Weight:10.6 ounces
- Recommended dog size:Small dogs
- Age range:Adult
Our verdict“Pick MON2SUN for a small adult dog that likes a changing assortment, but choose a more consistent calendar if ingredient predictability matters.”
Howliday 2026 Dog Christmas Advent Calendar, 25 Days of Treats, 3.5 oz
Howliday gives dogs a treat for 25 days, one more day than the 24-day formats from MON2SUN and Jungle Calling. Its treats are bone-shaped cakes with vanilla and honey, and the stated limited-ingredient, low-calorie profile will appeal to owners seeking a simpler, lighter holiday treat. It is also listed for all life stages and breed sizes, unlike MON2SUN, which is recommended for small adult dogs. The main compromise is the compact 3.5-ounce net weight: this calendar emphasizes a small daily treat rather than an abundant assortment of substantial chews or varied snacks. The ingredients may contain milk, soy, and wheat, so it is a poor match for dogs avoiding those allergens. Compared with Howliday’s 11-ounce calendar, this one favors the 25-day format and smaller portion total.
Pros:- Provides treats for 25 days, one day longer than a 24-day calendar.
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes.
- Limited-ingredient and low-calorie claims suit buyers seeking smaller treats.
- Made with human-grade ingredients in North America.
Cons:- The 3.5-ounce net weight makes it a compact treat offering.
- May contain milk, soy, and wheat.
- Cake treats in vanilla and honey offer less format variety than MON2SUN’s mixed assortment.
Best for: Owners who want a small, low-calorie holiday treat for every day of a 25-day countdown, including dogs of different sizes and life stages.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a high-volume treat assortment or dogs that must avoid milk, soy, or wheat.
- Brand:Howliday
- Treat count:25 days
- Net weight:3.5 ounces
- Flavor:Vanilla, honey
- Form and shape:Cake; dog bone shape
- Diet claims:Limited ingredient; low calorie
- Life stage and breed size:All life stages; all breed sizes
- Allergen information:May contain milk, soy, and wheat
- Made in:North America
Our verdict“Choose this Howliday calendar for a 25-day countdown of small, limited-ingredient treats, but check its allergen information and do not expect a large assortment.”
Jungle Calling 2026 Dog Advent Calendar, 24 Days of Holiday Treats
Jungle Calling is the broadest meat-forward assortment here, combining festive shapes, freeze-dried pieces, wraps, kabob meatballs, rolls, and sausages over 24 days. Its listed ingredients include chicken, beef, duck, fish, organs, sweet potato, banana, and peanuts, giving it a much more varied profile than the chicken-and-vanilla cakes in Howliday’s 25-day calendar. Real-meat ingredients, rawhide-free labeling, and claims of no artificial colors or flavors will appeal to owners who want a mixed savory countdown. The variety is also the key drawback: multiple animal proteins and peanuts make this a less suitable choice for dogs with sensitivities or carefully managed diets. The 7.2-ounce carton offers a moderate stated quantity, but the ingredient breadth matters more than simplicity for this pick.
Pros:- Offers 24 daily treats across several formats, including freeze-dried treats, wraps, meatballs, rolls, and sausages.
- Includes a broad mix of meat and other ingredients such as sweet potato and banana.
- Rawhide-free, with claims of no artificial colors or flavors.
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes.
Cons:- Multiple proteins, peanuts, and animal organs may not suit dogs with dietary restrictions.
- A broad ingredient mix makes it harder to keep treat ingredients consistent.
- The carton contains 7.2 ounces for 24 days, so individual daily portions may be small.
Best for: Owners of dogs without known ingredient sensitivities who enjoy varied, savory meat treats and different treat formats.
Not ideal for: Owners managing food sensitivities or avoiding specific proteins, peanuts, or animal organs; the varied ingredients make this a less predictable choice.
- Brand:Jungle Calling
- Countdown:24 days
- Treat varieties:Festive fun-shaped treats, freeze-dried treats, wraps, kabob meatballs, meat rolls, and sausages
- Special ingredients:Chicken heart, chicken liver, peanut bits
- Ingredient claims:No artificial colors; no artificial flavors
- Dietary information:Rawhide-free; high-protein claim
- Life stage and breed size:All life stages; all breed sizes
- Unit weight:7.2 ounces
- Container type:Carton
Our verdict“Choose Jungle Calling for a dog that enjoys varied, savory treats and tolerates a wide range of ingredients; skip it if dietary simplicity is a priority.”
Himalayan Dog Chew Advent Calendar for Dogs, 12 Full-Size Chews
Himalayan Dog Chew takes a shorter, chew-centered approach: 12 full-size treats rather than a small snack for each of 24 or 25 days. Its Churros and Yogurt Sticks are made with limited, natural ingredients, and the listed uses include training and general enjoyment. That makes it a better match for owners who value more substantial chews over a longer countdown, unlike SmartBones’ 24 mini chews, which are specifically aimed at small dogs. This calendar is listed for all life stages and sizes, but the source does not give chew dimensions or feeding guidance, so buyers should judge suitability for their individual dog. Its two treat varieties also mean less assortment than MON2SUN’s 10 types, and the seasonal, limited-edition format may be harder to find outside the holiday period.
Pros:- Includes 12 full-size chews for a shorter countdown.
- Combines Churros and Yogurt Sticks rather than offering just one treat type.
- Made with limited, natural ingredients.
- Listed for all life stages and breed sizes, with training and general enjoyment among the recommended uses.
Cons:- Provides 12 treats rather than a daily treat for a 24- or 25-day countdown.
- Two varieties offer less assortment than MON2SUN’s 10 treat varieties.
- Seasonal, limited-edition availability may restrict when it can be purchased.
Best for: Owners who prefer a 12-day holiday countdown with full-size chews for training rewards or general enjoyment.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a 24- or 25-day countdown, many different treat types, or clear listed chew dimensions before choosing.
- Brand:Himalayan Dog Chew
- Contents:12 full-size chews
- Treat varieties:Churros and Yogurt Sticks
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Age range:All life stages
- Breed size:All sizes
- Recommended uses:Daily use, training, general enjoyment
- Availability:Seasonal, limited-edition product
Our verdict“Pick Himalayan Dog Chew if you value 12 full-size chews more than a month-long countdown, and choose a 24-day calendar if daily variety is the priority.”
How We Picked
I compared these calendars on the details that shape a dog’s daily countdown: number of days and pieces, stated treat weight, treat style, and whether toys are included. I also looked at how clearly each option signals its intended dog or use, such as small-dog chews or a calendar built around full-size chews. Those distinctions matter more than festive packaging when the buyer needs a calendar that fits a dog’s appetite, chewing habits, and routine.
The ranking favors useful variety and a clear fit for a range of households, which puts BarkBox first for combining treats and toys. Treat-focused alternatives rank higher for buyers who want more edible options or a particular flavor style, while specialized or shorter-count calendars suit narrower needs. Product names and stated counts do not establish ingredient suitability or portion size for every dog, so I treat those as details shoppers should verify on the package rather than assume.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Dog Treat Advent Calendars
Before choosing, I’d match the calendar to the dog’s routine rather than judging it by its holiday theme. These products range from cookies and jerky to chews, toys, and a 12-piece format, so the right choice depends on what your dog can comfortably eat and enjoy.
Match the Treat Format to Your Dog
A calendar can contain treats your dog simply does not enjoy, so start with familiar formats: crunchy cookies, jerky, soft treats, or chews. If your dog has a sensitive stomach or follows a restricted diet, check the full ingredient list before opening the calendar; a flavor name alone does not tell you every ingredient. Avoid introducing several unfamiliar treats at once, since that makes it harder to identify what caused a reaction. A varied calendar can feel more festive, but a familiar single-style treat may be the safer choice for a dog with known sensitivities. Ask your veterinarian about ingredients or chewing habits that raise health concerns.
Check Portion Size, Not Just Total Weight
The total weight printed on a calendar does not tell you how large each daily serving is or how many pieces are behind each door. Compare the number of days and the stated weight, then consider how those treats fit alongside your dog’s regular meals and other snacks. Smaller dogs may need only part of a treat, while a large dog may find a tiny piece unsatisfying. Treats should fit within your dog’s daily feeding plan, so avoid treating a countdown as permission to add a full extra snack every day. If the package does not make portion sizes clear, inspect it before purchase or ask the seller for details.
Choose a Countdown Length That Fits Your Holiday
Most calendars in this group contain 24 days, but the Howliday options list 25 days and the Himalayan Dog Chew calendar contains 12 full-size chews. That difference can affect when you start the countdown and whether the calendar matches your household’s traditions. A 12-piece format may suit a dog that gets larger chews less often, but it is not a one-treat-per-day replacement for a 24-day calendar. Check whether the product specifies days, pieces, or both; those terms are not interchangeable. Choosing the count first helps prevent disappointment when the packaging arrives.
Decide Whether Toys Add Real Value
A toy-and-treat calendar offers something beyond food, but that mix only helps if your dog enjoys toys and you have a safe way to supervise play. With BarkBox’s eight toys and 16 treats, fewer calendar slots contain edible rewards than in a treat-only format. That can be a plus for homes trying to limit daily snacks, or a drawback for dogs that ignore toys. Check any toy’s size and construction against your dog’s chewing style, and remove damaged toys promptly. If toys are likely to go unused, a treat-focused calendar is the simpler buy.
Pay for Specialization Only When It Fits
Specialized calendars can solve a real mismatch: SmartBones is labeled for small dogs and rawhide-free chews, while the Himalayan option centers on 12 full-size chews. Those features are useful only when they match your dog’s size, chewing habits, and the care you want to take with chews. Do not assume that a product labeled for small dogs suits every small dog, or that rawhide-free means appropriate for all dogs. Read the feeding and supervision guidance on the package and ask your veterinarian if you are unsure. A more general cookie or jerky calendar may be a better fit when your dog has no need for a specialized format.
Plan for Storage and the Calendar’s Use Window
Once opened, a calendar may need different storage from an unopened box, especially if it contains treats that can dry out or lose freshness. Check packaging directions and reseal opened sections where possible; do not assume every door provides airtight storage. If you are buying early, verify the product’s date and storage instructions rather than relying on the holiday label alone. A 24- or 25-day countdown also means opening the calendar regularly, so place it where your dog cannot help themselves to future treats. This small planning step helps preserve the intended daily routine and keeps the calendar out of reach between openings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 25-day dog advent calendar better than a 24-day one?
Neither count is automatically better; the extra day matters only if it fits your countdown schedule. The Howliday calendars list 25 days, while many options here list 24, so check the start date you plan to use and how many openings the package actually provides. Also compare piece count with day count, since a listed number of days does not explain portion size. If your routine is built around 24 days, a 24-day calendar is the straightforward fit. Choose the longer format when you want an extra day and the treats suit your dog.
How do I choose a calendar for a dog with food sensitivities?
Read the complete ingredient and allergen information before buying, not just the flavor printed in the product name. A calendar with several treat types may expose your dog to more ingredients than a single-style option, so variety can be a drawback for dogs with known sensitivities. If the package information is incomplete or unclear, contact the manufacturer or choose a familiar treat your dog already tolerates. Introduce new treats cautiously and stop feeding them if your dog has an adverse reaction. Your veterinarian can help check whether a product fits a specific diet.
Should I choose a treat-only calendar or one that includes toys?
Choose based on what your dog will actually use and how many edible treats you want to give. BarkBox mixes eight toys with 16 treats, so it offers more variety beyond food but fewer treat portions than a treat-only calendar may provide. A toy can stretch the value of the countdown for a dog that enjoys play, while an uninterested dog may leave those items unused. Check toy size and suitability for your dog’s chewing style, and supervise play. For a dog that prefers food rewards, a treat-only format is likely the more direct match.
Is the 12-chew Himalayan calendar a substitute for a 24-day calendar?
Not if your goal is a treat for every day of a 24-day countdown: the Himalayan calendar lists 12 full-size chews. Its format is better understood as a smaller number of larger chew occasions, which may fit a household that does not want to give a daily treat. Consider your dog’s size, chewing habits, and the product’s feeding guidance before choosing full-size chews. Supervise chewing and follow the package directions. If you want a daily opening ritual, pick a calendar with a matching day count instead.
Does a higher total weight mean a calendar is better value for my dog?
Not by itself. The listed weight does not reveal how many treats are included, how large each serving is, or whether your dog can eat that style of treat. A larger calendar may be a poor fit if the pieces are too big for your dog’s daily treat plan or include flavors your dog avoids. Compare weight with count, ingredient information, and your dog’s usual portions rather than choosing by ounces alone. For a dog with a small appetite, a lower-weight calendar may create less waste.
Conclusion
For the best overall fit, I’d start with BarkBox if your dog enjoys toys as well as treats; it is the most varied format in this lineup. For a treat-focused option with a higher stated weight, compare MON2SUN at 10.6 oz with Howliday at 11 oz, and check their ingredients and serving details before choosing. I’d call the best value the calendar whose treats your dog will reliably eat and whose portions suit your routine, rather than the one with the largest stated weight. For a premium-style pick, Bonne et Filou offers a distinct 24-count alternative, while buyers seeking a beginner-friendly first calendar can favor a straightforward 24-day format with familiar treat styles. For specific needs, consider SmartBones for small dogs seeking rawhide-free chews or the Himalayan Dog Chew calendar if 12 full-size chews suit your schedule. Check package details and your dog’s dietary needs before making the final choice.
