The best puppy training supplies depend on whether your biggest challenge is potty training, rewarding good behavior, or helping a new puppy settle in. My best overall pick is Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats for small, reward-ready bites, while the Earth Rated XL Pee Pads stand out for indoor cleanup and the Dog Training Clickers offer a simple way to mark behavior. The main tradeoffs are convenience versus ongoing cleanup, reusable gear versus disposable supplies, and treat size or texture versus how often you plan to reward. No single kit fits every puppy or home setup. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching supplies to your routine.
Get pet supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Reward supplies serve different training styles: Pupford’s soft beef and chicken treats suit frequent reinforcement, while freeze-dried beef liver offers a firmer, single-ingredient-style alternative for dogs that prefer a different texture.
- Pad choice comes down to routine, not just size: Earth Rated and KISENG offer disposable options, Caldwell’s pads are washable, and Hompet adds a turf surface and tray for puppies learning to use a designated potty spot.
- Doorbell training and indoor potty setups solve different problems: KEXIAVA and Luckyiren bells teach a communication cue, while pads, grass, and BrilliantPad provide indoor elimination options.
- Automation trades hands-on cleanup for system dependence: BrilliantPad adds self-cleaning and app features, but it relies on a dedicated roll and more involved setup than a basic pad.
- Comfort and engagement matter alongside commands: N-Bone teething sticks and the Snuggle Puppy address chewing and settling, needs that treats, bells, and potty products do not cover.
| puppy training supplie | Brand |
|---|---|
| N-Bone Puppy Teething Sticks | N-Bone |
| Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee | — |
| KISENG Extra Large Dog Pee Pad | KISENG |
| KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training | KEXIAVA |
| Luckyiren Upgraded Puppy Bells | — |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Trai | Pupford |
| Dog Training Clickers with Spr | HoAoOo |
| Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Live | Pupford |
| Pupford Soft & Chewy Training | — |
| Hompet Large Dog Grass Pad wit | Hompet |
| Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog To | Snuggle Puppy |
| BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleani | — |
| Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reus | Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. |
| Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory | Blue Buffalo |
| Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Lamb | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
N-Bone Puppy Teething Sticks, Peanut Butter Flavor, 3.74 oz
For a puppy whose chewing ramps up as adult teeth come in, N-Bone Puppy Teething Sticks offer an edible alternative to a hard chew toy. Their pliable rice-based texture is intended to soothe sore gums, while calcium and DHA add nutrients beyond a basic chew. At 14 calories per treat, they can fit into a training routine more easily than larger snacks, though I would still count them toward daily food. Compared with Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, these are designed specifically for teething rather than frequent reward repetitions, so they make more sense as a chew-time option than a tiny training lure. The bag is puppy-focused, and the listing conflicts on flavor: the title says peanut butter, while another description says chicken. That uncertainty may put off buyers with flavor-sensitive dogs.
Pros:- Pliable texture is intended to soothe sore teething gums
- Edible rice-based formula is rawhide-free
- Free of corn, wheat, and soy
- Contains calcium and DHA, with 14 calories per treat
Cons:- Puppy-specific design may not suit adult dogs
- Flavor is unclear because the listing names both peanut butter and chicken
Best for: Puppy owners seeking a rawhide-free, edible chew for sore gums, especially those avoiding corn, wheat, and soy.
Not ideal for: Owners of adult dogs or puppies with a specific flavor preference, since the product is puppy-focused and the listing gives conflicting flavor information.
- Brand:N-Bone
- Flavor:Peanut butter in title and product details; chicken in item description
- Life stage:Puppy
- Form:Stick
- Weight:3.74 oz
- Count:1 bag
- Dietary features:Corn-free, wheat-free, soy-free, and rawhide-free
- Nutrition:14 calories per treat; low fat; calcium and DHA
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose these for a young puppy needing a softer edible teething chew, but skip them if flavor certainty or an adult-dog chew is your priority.”
Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee Pads, Discreet Top, Max Absorbency, 40CT
Earth Rated XL Pee Pads pair a built-in attractant with a large target, making them a useful choice for owners teaching a puppy where to go indoors. The brand says its AbsorbShield+ design absorbs liquid twice as fast and holds twice as much moisture, while adhesive tabs and layered construction help keep the pad in place and protect the floor. The discreet green surface is a practical touch in shared rooms. Compared with the KISENG Extra Large Dog Pee Pads, this option emphasizes an attractant and odor-conscious, unscented use rather than a larger 34-by-28-inch footprint. The 28-by-28-inch size may be easier to place in tighter areas, but still depends on the puppy aiming at the pad. The attractant may not appeal to every dog, and the thin profile offers little cushioning.
Pros:- AbsorbShield+ is described as absorbing twice as fast and holding twice as much moisture
- Layered design and adhesive tabs help limit leaks and pad movement
- Built-in attractant supports indoor potty training
- Unscented design and discreet green surface suit shared living spaces
Cons:- The 28-by-28-inch target may be less forgiving than the 34-by-28-inch KISENG pad
- Attractant effectiveness can vary between dogs
- Thin 0.04-inch profile provides little cushioning
Best for: Puppy owners training indoors who want an unscented pad with a built-in attractant and adhesive tabs for placement.
Not ideal for: Owners with large or inaccurate puppies who need the broadest target, or dogs that do not respond to attractants.
- Manufacturer:Earth Rated
- Dimensions:28 x 28 x 0.04 inches
- Pack count:40
- Item weight:8.29 pounds
- Absorbency:AbsorbShield+; listing states twice-as-fast absorption and twice the moisture capacity
- Leak protection:Layered design with adhesive tabs
- Surface:Discreet green
- Formula:Unscented with built-in attractant
- Model number:10EN10PD0023
Our verdict“Pick Earth Rated if an attractant and secure placement matter more than the extra width offered by the KISENG pads.”
KISENG Extra Large Dog Pee Pads – 40 Count, 34″ x 28″, Leak-Proof & Super Absorbent
When a puppy misses a smaller target or a household needs to protect a wider area, the KISENG 34-by-28-inch pads offer more coverage than the 28-by-28-inch Earth Rated XL pads. Their six-layer absorbent core is described as turning liquid into gel, while a reinforced PE backing helps shield floors and furniture from leaks. That larger surface can be especially useful for big puppies, multiple dogs, or a training area that doubles as furniture protection. The tradeoff is space: these pads may overwhelm a small crate or a cramped corner, and the supplied details do not mention an attractant like Earth Rated’s. A 40-count pack supports ongoing indoor training, but buyers should measure the intended spot before choosing the wider format.
Pros:- 34-by-28-inch surface gives puppies a larger target than the Earth Rated 28-by-28-inch pads
- Six-layer core is designed to lock liquid into gel and keep paws dry
- Reinforced PE backing helps protect floors and furniture
- 40-pad pack supports repeated indoor training
Cons:- Large footprint may not fit small crates or limited spaces
- No built-in attractant is listed, unlike the Earth Rated pads
- The product details do not specify an individual pad thickness
Best for: Owners of large puppies or multiple dogs who need a broad indoor target and leak protection for floors or furniture.
Not ideal for: People using small crates or compact potty stations, where the 34-inch length may take up too much room.
- Brand:KISENG
- Model number:DTP-40PCS
- Pad dimensions:34 x 28 inches
- Count:40
- Material:Polyethylene (PE)
- Number of layers:6
- Color:Blue
- Core:Super-absorbent core described as turning liquid into gel
- Backing:Reinforced PE leak-proof backing
Our verdict“Choose KISENG for a roomy, leak-conscious training area, but choose Earth Rated if compact placement and a listed attractant matter more.”
KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training Bells, 2 Pack, Pink
KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training Bells give puppy owners two adjustable door-hanging signals for teaching a dog to ask for an outdoor trip. At 33–35 inches long, the strap can be set to suit different handles and a puppy’s reach; the stainless steel bells are intended to make the cue audible. Unlike pee pads such as the Earth Rated XL pads, this set teaches a communication behavior rather than providing an indoor backup, so it suits owners focused on getting the puppy to the door. It does require regular practice and rewards, and a bell alone will not prevent accidents while the habit is forming. The listing also has inconsistent bell-count and quantity wording, so I would verify what is included before relying on the two-pack claim.
Pros:- Two-pack can provide bells for separate exits or locations
- Adjustable 33–35-inch length fits a range of handles
- Stainless steel bells are designed for a clear audible cue
- Can be taught with repeated practice and rewards
Cons:- Puppies need consistent training before the bell becomes a reliable signal
- Bell count and pack quantity are described inconsistently
- Does not absorb or contain accidents like the Earth Rated pads
Best for: Puppy owners who want to teach a door signal and need adjustable straps for more than one door or handle.
Not ideal for: Owners seeking immediate accident protection or a no-training potty aid; the puppy must learn to ring the bells, and the listing’s quantity details are inconsistent.
- Brand:KEXIAVA
- Quantity:Listed as 2 pack; bell-count wording is inconsistent
- Color:Pink
- Adjustable length:33–35 inches
- Bell material:Stainless steel
- Bell size:1.4 inches
- Product diameter:2.8 inches (7.2 cm)
- Item weight:5.9 oz
- Model number:00
Our verdict“Choose this set to teach a puppy to signal at the door, but keep pads available until the cue is learned.”
Luckyiren Upgraded Puppy Bells Dog Doorbells for Door Knob Potty Training – Premium Quality, Adjustable Length (3 Snaps)
For a household that needs one door signal fitted to a particular handle, the Luckyiren Puppy Bells keep adjustment straightforward with three snap positions on a nylon strap. The bright jingle is meant to help a puppy associate ringing with going outside, and the single-bell setup avoids buying a two-pack when only one exit is used for potty trips. Compared with the KEXIAVA Dog Doorbell Training Bells, Luckyiren offers three defined strap settings rather than a listed adjustable 33–35-inch range, while KEXIAVA supplies two bells. This set is a better fit for buyers who value a simple, adjustable installation, not multiple locations. It still depends on consistent reward-based practice, and the listing describes the bell material as iron with a stainless steel core, so it is not quite the same material claim as KEXIAVA’s stainless steel bells.
Pros:- Three snap positions allow adjustment for different dogs and door handles
- Clear, crisp jingle provides an audible potty signal
- Nylon strap is designed for repeated hanging and use
- Single pack suits homes with one main potty-training exit
Cons:- Requires consistent practice and rewards before a puppy uses it reliably
- Only one bell set is included, unlike the KEXIAVA two-pack
- Bell material is described as iron with a stainless steel core, rather than as stainless steel throughout
Best for: Puppy owners training at one main exit who want a doorbell strap with three snap-adjustable lengths.
Not ideal for: Households that want bells at multiple doors or prefer a clearly specified stainless steel bell; KEXIAVA is listed as a two-pack with stainless steel bells.
- Pack size:1
- Item dimensions:32 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches
- Package dimensions:6.81 x 5.43 x 1.96 inches
- Item weight:3.84 ounces
- Color:Black
- Strap material:Nylon
- Bell material:Iron with stainless steel core
- Adjustment:Three snap positions
- Warranty:2-year manufacturer warranty
Our verdict“Pick Luckyiren for one adjustable training bell at a primary exit; choose KEXIAVA if you need a second location covered.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats for Dogs and Puppies, 5 oz
For training sessions that call for many small rewards, Pupford’s soft beef bites pair an easy-to-chew texture with less than 2 calories per treat. The 250+ pieces per pouch give handlers plenty of opportunities to reward without breaking larger treats into bits, and the soft texture may be easier for puppies and senior dogs to eat than the freeze-dried pieces in Pupford Beef Liver Training Treats. Compared with that liver option, these are chewy rather than crisp and use beef with sweet potato as their named ingredients. The tradeoff is that the pouch is a single-flavor choice, and beef makes it unsuitable for dogs with beef sensitivities. I’d choose these for routine, high-repetition practice, but not for a dog that needs a non-beef reward.
Pros:- Less than 2 calories per treat suits frequent reinforcement.
- Bite-sized pieces help keep reward timing quick.
- Soft, chewy texture may suit dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Made in the USA with limited ingredients and no artificial colors or flavors.
Cons:- Beef may not suit dogs with beef sensitivities.
- One pouch offers only a single flavor.
- Soft treats may be less convenient than the freeze-dried Pupford liver treats for handlers who prioritize a dry, lightweight reward.
Best for: Handlers who want many small, soft rewards for repeated puppy cues, including senior dogs that prefer an easier-to-chew treat.
Not ideal for: Dogs with beef sensitivities, or owners seeking a flavor other than beef.
- Brand:Pupford
- Flavor:Beef
- Weight:5 oz
- Treat count:250+ per bag
- Calories per treat:Less than 2 kcal
- Life stage:All life stages
- Diet type:Limited ingredient
- Made in:USA
Our verdict“Choose these for frequent training with small, soft beef rewards, unless your dog needs a different protein.”
Dog Training Clickers with Spring Wrist Straps and Keyrings, 2-Pack
This two-clicker set offers a way to mark the exact moment a puppy does the right thing, which can make reward-based lessons more consistent than relying on a treat alone. The black and blue pair is useful for keeping a clicker in separate training areas or giving a second handler their own; unlike Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, clickers do not add calories, though they work best alongside a reward the dog values. The wrist straps extend from 16 to 25 cm, giving some flexibility for wearing or retrieving the device. The product information does not specify sound volume or durability, and the strap description is unclear, so I wouldn’t pick it for buyers who need documented construction details or a sound that can be judged in advance.
Pros:- A click marks desired behavior without adding food calories.
- Two clickers support separate training locations or handlers.
- Different colors make the units easier to tell apart.
- Extending spring wrist straps offer flexible wear and access.
Cons:- No durability details are provided.
- Sound volume is unspecified, so suitability for different environments is hard to judge.
- The wrist-strap wording is unclear, leaving fit and use less certain.
Best for: New puppy handlers and multi-person households practicing reward-based cues who want a clicker available in more than one place.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed durability or sound-volume information, or anyone seeking a complete training kit with rewards included.
- Brand:HoAoOo
- Model:ch-clicker01
- Package quantity:2
- Colors:Black and blue
- Wrist strap length:16 cm (6.3 in), extends to 25 cm (9.84 in)
- Item weight:1.45 oz (41 g)
- Target animals:Dogs, horses, cats, and birds
Our verdict“Pick this pair if you want a simple marker tool for reward-based practice and can accept limited detail about sound and build.”
Pupford Freeze-Dried Beef Liver Training Treats for Dogs and Puppies, 4 oz
For training away from home, freeze-dried beef liver offers a lightweight, low-mess format that is easier to carry than the larger Hompet Grass Pad or other potty gear in this roundup. The bag lists 475+ bite-sized pieces, giving handlers a substantial supply for short practice sessions and outings. Compared with Pupford’s soft beef treats, these are pellets rather than chewy bites, so they may be less suitable for dogs that need a softer texture. The three-ingredient, limited-ingredient formula is a straightforward option for owners who want a compact reward, but beef liver is still beef, so it won’t suit every dog. I’d choose this over soft treats when portability and low mess matter more than a chewy texture.
Pros:- 475+ pieces per bag support many small rewards.
- Lightweight, mess-free form is convenient for carrying on outings.
- Made with three ingredients and described as low-calorie.
- Suitable for all life stages and breed sizes.
Cons:- Beef liver may not suit dogs with beef sensitivities.
- Pellet texture is less soft than Pupford’s soft and chewy training treats.
- The supplied product data does not state calories per treat.
Best for: Puppy owners who train during walks, classes, or trips and want a lightweight, bite-sized reward with a short ingredient list.
Not ideal for: Dogs with beef sensitivities or dogs that need soft treats because they struggle with firmer textures.
- Brand:Pupford
- Flavor:Beef liver
- Weight:4 oz
- Ingredients:3
- Treat count:475+ per bag
- Form:Pellet
- Life stage:All life stages
- Breed size:All breed sizes
Our verdict“Choose these for portable, low-mess training rewards if your dog enjoys beef and does well with pellet-textured treats.”
Pupford Soft & Chewy Training Treats for Dogs & Puppies (Chicken, 5 oz)
These soft chicken bites suit handlers who want a quick, easy-to-chew reward without switching to a dry pellet. Each bite contains less than 2 calories, which helps when a puppy needs frequent reinforcement, and the one-bite size can keep sessions moving without stopping to break treats apart. Compared with Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats, the main choice is protein: this version is chicken rather than beef, while both are soft and low-calorie. That makes the chicken pouch a practical alternative for dogs that prefer chicken, but it does not solve sensitivities to chicken and offers only one flavor. I’d favor this over Pupford Beef Liver when a softer texture matters more than a lightweight, freeze-dried format.
Pros:- Less than 2 calories per bite supports frequent rewards.
- One-bite size helps preserve training pace.
- Soft texture may be gentler for senior dogs with sensitive teeth.
- Made in the USA with simple ingredients.
Cons:- Single chicken flavor may not appeal to every dog.
- Chicken is unsuitable for dogs with chicken sensitivities.
- The supplied product details do not include a treat count or specific ingredient list.
Best for: Puppy owners seeking small, soft chicken rewards for frequent practice, especially when a dog prefers chewy treats or has sensitive teeth.
Not ideal for: Dogs with chicken sensitivities, or owners who want multiple flavors or a freeze-dried treat for carrying with minimal mess.
- Weight:5 oz
- Flavor:Chicken
- Calories per treat:Less than 2 kcal
- Protein:High
- Made in:USA
- Texture:Soft and chewy
- Treat size:One-bite
Our verdict“Pick this pouch for frequent, soft chicken rewards; choose Pupford’s freeze-dried liver instead if portability and a dry texture matter more.”
Hompet Large Dog Grass Pad with Tray, 41 x 27 Inches, Reusable Turf and Washable Pee Pads
For house-training puppies in apartments or homes without easy outdoor access, this large reusable potty system provides a designated indoor spot rather than another disposable pad. Its turf, drainage insert, collection tray, and two washable pee pads work together to direct urine away from the surface; unlike the single-use Earth Rated XL Dog & Puppy Pee Pads, the components can be washed and reused. At 41 x 27 inches, it offers more room than a small training mat, but that footprint also demands dedicated floor space. Cleaning is an ongoing job: the turf, pads, and tray all need regular washing. I’d choose it for households prioritizing reuse and indoor-outdoor flexibility, not for buyers who want a low-maintenance or compact potty solution.
Pros:- Reusable turf and two washable pee pads reduce reliance on disposable pads.
- Drainage insert and collection tray help keep urine off the floor.
- Can be used indoors or outdoors.
- No assembly is required.
Cons:- The 41 x 27-inch footprint takes substantial floor space.
- Turf, pads, and tray require regular cleaning.
- At 4.76 kg, it is less convenient to move than a simple pee pad.
Best for: Apartment residents and caregivers of large or young dogs who need a roomy, reusable potty area for indoor use or outdoor placement.
Not ideal for: People with limited floor space or those who prefer disposable pads and want to avoid washing turf, pads, and a collection tray.
- Brand:Hompet
- Size:41 x 27 inches
- Item dimensions:40.75 x 25.98 x 1.18 inches
- Item weight:4.76 kg
- Included replacement turf:2 pieces
- Material:Plastic
- Use:Indoor and outdoor
- Assembly:None required
Our verdict“Choose this if you need a roomy, reusable indoor potty station and are willing to clean its parts regularly.”
Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Dog Toy – Brown & White Beagle
The removable heartbeat device gives this plush companion a different job from potty pads and food rewards: it may help a puppy settle when crate time or travel feels unfamiliar. The included disposable heat pack adds littermate-like warmth, while the washable polyester exterior makes routine cleanup more manageable. Compared with the BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleaning Indoor Dog Potty, this is aimed at comfort rather than handling accidents, so it suits a puppy whose main training hurdle is settling alone—not one who needs a toileting solution. The tradeoff is ongoing upkeep: heat packs need replacing, and you must remove the internal components before washing. I’d also avoid treating it as a substitute for gradual crate acclimation or supervision, since it is a plush toy with removable parts.
Pros:- Heartbeat device and heat pack are designed to mimic littermate comfort
- May support settling during crate training, travel, or stressful situations
- Machine-washable polyester exterior
- Suitable for dogs of all breed sizes
Cons:- Heat packs are disposable and need replacement
- Heartbeat device and heat pack must be removed before washing
- No warranty is listed
Best for: Puppy owners working on crate settling or travel who want a comfort item with a heartbeat feature
Not ideal for: Owners seeking potty-training cleanup help, or puppies that chew plush toys and may reach removable internal parts
- Brand:Snuggle Puppy
- Model:SP104
- Material:Polyester
- Color:Brown & White
- Dimensions:12 x 6.5 x 5 inches
- Weight:16 ounces
- Included components:Heartbeat device and heat pack
- Water resistance:Water resistant
Our verdict“Choose this comfort-focused toy for a puppy struggling to settle; pick a potty pad or indoor potty instead if toileting is the training priority.”
BrilliantPad Smart Self-Cleaning Indoor Dog Potty with Smartphone App and 1 Roll
For owners who need an indoor toileting station and want less hands-on pad handling, the automatic pad advancement and waste wrapping and sealing set this apart from reusable mats such as Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reusable Washable Dog Pee Pads. The BrilliantPad connects to Wi-Fi and an app, with a camera and health insights adding monitoring features beyond a basic pad. Its single roll is stated to equal 21 traditional puppy pads, which can help reduce frequent pad changes, though the device still depends on the dog accepting an indoor pad routine. The main limit is fit: it is designed for dogs under 25 pounds and is not intended for large dogs or adult dogs that do not already use pads. At 34 by 24 inches, it also takes dedicated floor space.
Pros:- Automatically advances a fresh pad after use
- Wraps and seals used pads to help contain mess and odors
- App connectivity, camera, and health insights provide added monitoring
- Included roll is equivalent to 21 traditional puppy pads
Cons:- Designed for dogs under 25 pounds
- Not suited to dogs that do not already use indoor pads
- Requires a dedicated 34-by-24-inch floor area and Wi-Fi for connected features
Best for: Households with a small puppy already learning to use pads, especially owners seeking automated waste handling
Not ideal for: Owners of dogs over 25 pounds, dogs trained to toilet outdoors, or buyers who want a simple washable mat without Wi-Fi features
- Suitable dog size:Under 25 pounds
- Dimensions:34 x 24 x 6 inches
- Weight:10 pounds
- Included:1 puppy pad roll
- Pad roll equivalent:21 traditional puppy pads
- Connectivity:Wi-Fi and smartphone app
- Features:Camera, automatic pad advancement, waste wrapping and sealing
Our verdict“Pick the BrilliantPad for a small, pad-using puppy when automated cleanup matters more than a compact or washable setup.”
Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co. Reusable Washable Dog Pee Pads (30×36, Set of 2)
This two-pad set is the reusable alternative for puppy owners who want a washable surface for indoor training, travel, or whelping areas. Its five-layer construction and waterproof TPU backing are intended to absorb urine while protecting the floor beneath, and having two pads lets one remain available while the other is being washed. Compared with the BrilliantPad, Caldwell’s has no automatic advancement, app, or waste-sealing system; in return, it avoids a device-based setup and can be used as a simple mat. The tradeoff is laundry: the care instructions call for cold washing, low tumble drying, and no bleach or fabric softener. Its 30-by-36-inch size is geared toward medium dogs, so it may be too small for larger puppies or broad training areas.
Pros:- Five-layer construction is designed for high absorbency
- Waterproof TPU backing helps protect floors
- Two pads allow one to be in use while the other is washed
- Machine- or hand-washable and backed by a one-year manufacturer-defect warranty
Cons:- Requires specific washing and drying care
- 30-by-36-inch size may not suit large dogs or wide areas
- Does not advance or seal used pads like the BrilliantPad
Best for: Owners of medium-sized puppies who want a washable indoor potty surface for repeated use or travel
Not ideal for: People who prefer not to do regular laundry, need automated waste handling, or need a larger mat for a big dog
- Brand:Caldwell’s Pet Supply Co.
- Dimensions:30 x 36 inches
- Quantity:2 pads
- Construction:Five-layer design
- Backing:Thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU)
- Care:Cold machine or hand wash; tumble dry low; no bleach or fabric softener
- Warranty:1 year against manufacturer defects
Our verdict“Choose this set if you want a repeat-use potty mat and can keep up with its laundry and care requirements.”
Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE Savory Chicken Puppy Training Treats, 4 oz
These tender, bite-sized chicken treats are suited to short training repetitions, where a quick reward can help mark a behavior without interrupting the session for a large chew. Real chicken is the first ingredient, and the recipe includes DHA while avoiding corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives. Compared with Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Lamb and Salmon, Baby BLUE keeps the flavor centered on chicken rather than combining two meats, which may make it the clearer pick for owners looking for that protein profile. The package is only four ounces, however, so frequent reward-based practice may use it up quickly. It is formulated for puppies, not adult dogs, and owners should account for treats within the puppy’s overall feeding plan.
Pros:- Real chicken is the first ingredient
- Tender, bite-sized texture suits quick training rewards
- Contains DHA
- Free from corn, wheat, soy, and artificial preservatives
Cons:- Four-ounce bag may run out quickly during frequent sessions
- Formulated for puppies rather than adult dogs
- Chicken-focused recipe is not suited to buyers seeking another protein flavor
Best for: Puppy owners who want small, soft chicken rewards for frequent basic obedience and manners practice
Not ideal for: Owners seeking a larger training supply, an adult-dog treat, or a lamb-and-salmon recipe
- Brand:Blue Buffalo
- Flavor:Savory chicken
- Age range:Puppy
- Form:Semi-moist
- Package weight:4 ounces
- Key ingredients:Real chicken and DHA
- Allergen information:Corn-free, soy-free, and wheat-free
Our verdict“Choose Baby BLUE for small chicken rewards during puppy training, but plan for a larger supply if you train often.”
Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Lamb and Salmon Dog Training Treats, Grain Free, 3 oz
Wellness Soft Puppy Bites offer a lamb-and-salmon recipe for owners who want a different protein profile from the chicken-based Blue Buffalo Baby BLUE treats. Their soft, bite-sized form is practical for training, while DHA and added vitamins give the formula a puppy-focused nutritional angle. Blueberries and sweet potatoes add fruit and vegetable ingredients, and the recipe excludes meat byproducts, artificial colors, and artificial flavors. The small three-ounce package is easy to portion into a training kit, but it may need frequent replacement during daily practice and is smaller than Baby BLUE’s four-ounce bag. This is a puppy-specific treat, not a general choice for adult dogs; buyers seeking a grain-inclusive formula should also look elsewhere.
Pros:- Soft, bite-sized pieces suit training sessions
- Made with lamb and salmon
- Contains DHA and added vitamins
- No meat byproducts, artificial colors, or artificial flavors
Cons:- Three-ounce package may not last through frequent training
- Formulated specifically for puppies
- Grain-free recipe does not fit buyers seeking grain-inclusive treats
Best for: Puppy owners seeking soft training rewards made with lamb and salmon, plus DHA and added vitamins
Not ideal for: Owners who need adult-dog treats, a larger bag for frequent sessions, or a grain-inclusive recipe
- Product type:Soft puppy training treats
- Flavor:Lamb and salmon
- Dietary feature:Grain free
- Package size:3 ounces
- Key ingredients:Lamb, salmon, blueberries, and sweet potatoes
- Added nutrients:Vitamins and DHA
- Excluded ingredients:Meat byproducts, artificial colors, and artificial flavors
Our verdict“Choose Wellness Soft Puppy Bites for a soft lamb-and-salmon reward; opt for Baby BLUE if you prefer chicken or a slightly larger package.”
How We Picked
I compared these 15 supplies by the puppy-training problem each one helps solve: rewarding behavior, building a potty routine, communicating a need to go out, managing teething, or supporting rest. Within each group, I weighed practical fit, ease of use, cleanup or maintenance, and how readily the product can work as part of a consistent routine. A useful training supply should support teaching; it cannot replace supervision, regular bathroom breaks, or a reward plan suited to the individual puppy.
The ranking gives priority to versatile, straightforward tools that can help many households establish daily habits, then places more specialized or setup-dependent products lower. That is why reward treats and accessible potty aids lead, while reusable, turf, and automated systems are framed around specific home needs rather than treated as universal upgrades. The list includes several products with similar roles, so differences in format and maintenance matter more than minor variations in branding. I also weighed tradeoffs: washable pads require laundering, treats need portion control, and electronic or turf systems ask for more upkeep than a simple bell or clicker.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Puppy Training Supplies
Choosing puppy supplies is less about assembling the biggest kit and more about matching tools to the habits you want to teach and the space you have. I would start with the puppy’s daily routine, then choose gear that makes the desired behavior clear and repeatable.
Choose rewards your puppy can eat often
Training may involve many repetitions, so a treat that is easy to break or deliver quickly can keep practice moving. Soft, chewy pieces and freeze-dried pieces offer different textures; a puppy that gulps treats may need smaller portions, while a picky eater may respond to a more enticing option. Check the feeding guidance and count training rewards as part of the day’s food rather than treating them as unlimited extras. A common mistake is choosing a large treat that takes too long to chew during a short lesson. You can also use part of the puppy’s regular food for familiar skills and reserve special treats for harder distractions. Introduce new foods gradually, especially if your puppy has a sensitive stomach or known dietary restrictions.
Match the potty setup to your home and schedule
Disposable pads can simplify immediate cleanup, while washable pads reduce throwaway waste but create a laundry task. Turf systems can provide a different surface cue from a flat pad, though the tray and reusable grass need regular cleaning. Automated indoor potties may appeal when a puppy must stay inside for longer stretches, but they bring setup, supplies, and maintenance that a basic pad does not. Think about where the toilet area will sit, whether the puppy can reach it, and how you will clean it without disrupting the routine. Avoid moving the designated spot repeatedly; changing locations can make the cue harder to learn. Indoor options work best as part of a clear plan, not as a substitute for outdoor breaks when those are appropriate.
Decide whether reusable gear fits your cleanup habits
Reusable pads can be a good fit for households that can wash them promptly and keep a clean spare available. Disposable pads make replacement simple, which may matter during early training when accidents are frequent. A pad’s dimensions should match the puppy’s current aim and the space available, but a larger surface does not fix inconsistent placement or missed bathroom timing. Check whether the product’s materials and care instructions fit your washer and cleaning routine before buying several. The common mistake is comparing only the upfront format while ignoring storage, laundry, replacement supplies, and odor control. Choose the system you can maintain every day, since neglected cleanup can make any potty area less appealing.
Use bells and clickers as clear cues, not shortcuts
A doorbell can give a puppy a way to signal, but the puppy still needs to learn that ringing it leads to a bathroom trip. Place bells where they are reachable and respond consistently, while keeping an eye out for play-ringing or requests that are not tied to elimination. A clicker serves a different purpose: it marks the exact behavior you want to reward, such as sitting calmly or touching the bells. The click itself is not a reward, so pair it with food or another valued reinforcer. New handlers can keep the process simple by teaching one cue at a time and rewarding promptly. Buying both tools can help, but using inconsistent signals may confuse the routine rather than speed it up.
Cover comfort needs without confusing them with training
Chew items and settling toys can support a puppy through teething or a new sleeping environment, but they do not teach potty habits or replace supervised play. Select chew products appropriate to the puppy’s age, size, and chewing style, and follow the maker’s guidance. A heartbeat-style comfort toy may help some puppies settle, while others may ignore it or prefer a different sleep setup. Supervise new toys and remove damaged pieces to reduce the chance of swallowing loose material. Avoid leaving a puppy with any item that is not suitable for unsupervised use. These supplies are most useful when they address a specific comfort or chewing need alongside a separate training plan.
Pay more only when the added system solves a real problem
Premium or specialized supplies make sense when they reduce a recurring burden, not simply because they have more features. An automated potty may be relevant for a household with a specific indoor-use need, while a straightforward pad or scheduled outdoor breaks may be easier for other homes. Reusable products can lower disposable use but require cleaning time; treats with a particular ingredient or texture may suit a puppy’s preferences but are not automatically better for every dog. Before buying, ask what task the extra feature removes and what new upkeep it adds. Start with the smallest set of tools that supports your routine, then add equipment only after you can identify a gap. This approach helps prevent unused gadgets and duplicate supplies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I buy pee pads if I ultimately want my puppy to go outside?
Pads can help when a puppy cannot get outdoors promptly, but they can also establish an indoor surface habit that you may later need to change. If outdoor toileting is your goal, keep outdoor breaks frequent and reward them consistently instead of relying on pads as the main routine. If you need an indoor option, designate one location and avoid spreading pads through the home. Gradually adjust the plan as your puppy gains bladder control and your schedule allows. The right choice depends on access, supervision, and how consistently everyone in the household follows the same routine.
Are washable puppy pads better than disposable ones?
Neither format is better for every household: washable pads trade repeat purchasing and disposal for laundry, drying, and having clean spares ready. Disposable pads are easier to replace quickly, which can be helpful during a messy early training stage or when laundry access is limited. Compare the size and placement you need, then think through the cleanup routine you can sustain each day. If a washable pad stays damp or unwashed, its reuse advantage may not suit your household. Some owners use both formats for different locations or situations.
Can I use a clicker and a doorbell together?
Yes, because they serve separate roles: a doorbell can become the puppy’s signal to go out, while a clicker marks a behavior you want to reinforce. Teach each action clearly and pair the click with a reward so it has meaning. When training the bell, take the puppy outside after the cue and reward bathroom success, rather than treating the bell ring alone as the finished task. If the puppy starts ringing for attention or play, calmly keep the response consistent and observe whether a bathroom break is needed. Using both tools works best when all household members follow the same cues.
How should I choose between soft training treats and freeze-dried treats?
Start with what your puppy can eat quickly and reliably during repeated practice. Soft treats are often easy to portion, while freeze-dried options provide a different texture that some puppies may prefer. Check ingredient information and feeding guidance, particularly if your puppy has dietary sensitivities, and introduce new treats in small amounts. For short sessions, small pieces help avoid filling the puppy too quickly. You can keep more than one reward option and use the more motivating choice for work around distractions.
Is an automated indoor potty a good choice for a new puppy?
It may suit a home with a clear need for an indoor toilet area and a caregiver prepared to manage setup, ongoing supplies, and cleaning. It is not a replacement for teaching where and when to go, supervising the puppy, or providing suitable breaks. Compare its maintenance needs with a basic pad or reusable turf system before committing to a more involved setup. Consider where the unit will fit and whether the puppy can approach it comfortably. If your puppy is learning an outdoor routine and can go out regularly, a simpler arrangement may be easier to manage.
Conclusion
For most households, I would start with Pupford Soft & Chewy Beef Training Treats as the best overall training reward, paired with a potty option suited to the home. For best value, the two-pack of Dog Training Clickers provides a straightforward marker for teaching behaviors, while best premium goes to BrilliantPad for buyers who specifically want an automated indoor potty system and accept its added upkeep. Beginners can build a clear routine with Earth Rated XL Pee Pads and a simple treat reward before adding more tools. For washable-pad needs, choose Caldwell’s Reusable Pads; for a turf-style potty area, consider Hompet; and for door communication, compare the KEXIAVA and Luckyiren bells. Add N-Bone teething sticks or the Snuggle Puppy only when chewing or settling is a real need, rather than treating comfort products as substitutes for training.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
