Choosing the right 12×24 shed from Astoria means balancing size, customization, and ease of assembly. The Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit stands out for its expansive interior and flexible door placement, making it a strong choice for those needing large, customizable storage or a workshop space. Meanwhile, the Westfield 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed offers durable construction, ready-to-customize surfaces, and included features like a loft and window, making it ideal for outdoor equipment storage. Both options involve significant assembly and additional costs for paint or shingles, but they serve different priorities—space versus built-in features. Here’s a detailed look at each to help you decide which fits your needs best.
Get pet supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Astoria 12×24 sheds are both large enough for extensive storage or workshop use, with flexible door placement options.
- Assembly complexity varies, with both models requiring time and effort, especially for beginners.
- Customization options like paint, shingles, and interior layouts can significantly impact final costs and setup time.
- The Astoria 12×24 Wooden Shed offers maximum interior space, while the Westfield version emphasizes durability and built-in features.
- Choosing the right shed depends on whether you prioritize raw space or integrated features and ease of customization.
| Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit |  | Best Overall for Space & Customization | Item Dimensions: 157.44″D x 290.69″W x 119″H | Item Weight: 3003 pounds | Floor Area: 288 square feet | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Westfield 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit |  | Best for Durability & Built-in Features | Size: 12×24 feet | Material: Treated engineered wood | Floor: Included | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| astoria 12×24 shed review | Item Dimensions | Item Weight | Floor Area | Door Width |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage S | 157.44"D x 290.69"W x 119"H | 3003 pounds | 288 square feet | 64 inches |
| Westfield 12×24 Wooden Storage | — | — | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit
This shed stands out for its impressive 288 square feet of interior space, making it a prime choice for those who need a versatile workshop or large storage area. Its tall side walls and customizable door placement offer flexibility for large equipment or interior layout changes. The pre-cut, pre-assembled components make DIY assembly easier, but the weight of over 3000 pounds means you’ll likely need multiple people or equipment to set it up. The absence of paint or shingles means additional costs and effort for weatherproofing. Compared with the Westfield, it provides more interior room but demands more effort to finish and install.
Pros:- Large 288 sq ft interior space
- Flexible door placement options
- Tall side walls for maximum headroom
- Pre-cut, pre-assembled components simplify DIY
Cons:- Does not include paint or shingles, sold separately
- Heavy weight complicates installation
- Assembly can be time-consuming for beginners
Best for: Homeowners needing a large, customizable workshop or storage space that can be tailored to specific needs.
Not ideal for: Beginners or those seeking a quick, no-fuss setup without the need for additional customization.
- Item Dimensions:157.44″D x 290.69″W x 119″H
- Item Weight:3003 pounds
- Floor Area:288 square feet
- Door Width:64 inches
- Chamber Depth:157.44 inches
Our verdict“A spacious, customizable shed ideal for DIYers willing to invest time and effort into assembly.”
Westfield 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit
The Westfield shed emphasizes sturdy construction with treated engineered wood siding, providing a durable exterior ready for painting and shingling. It includes a built-in storage loft for efficient space utilization and a window that brightens the interior, making it suitable for outdoor tools and lawn equipment. Its extra-wide double doors facilitate easy access for larger items. Compared with the Astoria model, it trades off some interior space for added features and durability, but assembly still requires at least two adults and a significant time investment. Additional costs for paint and shingles are necessary, but the included floor simplifies setup.
Pros:- Includes a built-in loft and window for natural light
- Heavy-duty construction withstands weather
- Extra-wide double doors for easy access
- Pre-installed floor for quicker setup
Cons:- Assembly takes around 32 hours and needs 2 adults
- Paint and shingles are sold separately
- Tools are not included, requiring additional purchase
Best for: Garden or outdoor enthusiasts seeking a durable, feature-rich shed with built-in storage options.
Not ideal for: Those who need maximum interior space or want a quick setup without additional work on finishing.
- Size:12×24 feet
- Material:Treated engineered wood
- Floor:Included
- Doors:64-inch double
- Assembly Time:32 hours
- Tools Needed:Power tools (not included)
Our verdict“A durable, feature-rich shed that balances built-in amenities with the need for a substantial assembly effort.”
How We Picked
To select the best Astoria 12×24 sheds, I looked at detailed product specifications, customer reviews, and manufacturer descriptions. I prioritized sheds with ample size, customizable features, and reasonable assembly requirements. I also considered the durability of materials, included components like floors and doors, and evaluated the tradeoffs involved—such as extra costs for paint or shingles and assembly complexity. My goal was to identify options that serve different buyer needs, from DIY enthusiasts to those seeking ready-to-use storage solutions, ensuring each pick offers a clear advantage and a notable tradeoff.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Astoria 12×24 Shed Review
Selecting the right 12×24 shed from Astoria depends on your storage needs, DIY skills, and whether you prioritize space or built-in features. Both options are customizable, but they differ in their setup complexity and final use case. Understanding these differences can help you make a choice that aligns with your project goals and budget.Size and Interior Space
The 12×24 dimension provides ample room for tools, equipment, or workspace. The Astoria wooden shed offers the most interior space with 288 square feet, ideal for those planning a workshop or large storage area. The Westfield also provides 12×24 feet but emphasizes durability and features like a loft, which can impact usable space. Consider your storage volume and whether interior customization or additional features matter most for your needs.
Construction and Materials
The Astoria shed uses pre-primed, treated wood with a straightforward DIY assembly process but requires substantial effort and additional weatherproofing materials. The Westfield employs treated engineered wood siding, offering greater durability out of the box, especially in harsh weather, but with a longer assembly time. Think about your climate and how much effort you’re willing to put into maintenance or finishing.
Features and Customization
The Astoria model provides flexible door placement and a large interior space, making it suitable for those wanting a blank canvas. The Westfield includes a built-in loft, window, and wide double doors, making it more suited for users wanting ready-to-use features and natural light. Decide if built-in amenities are a priority or if you prefer to customize your shed over time.
Assembly and Cost
Both sheds require a significant time investment—around 32 hours for the Westfield and potentially more for the Astoria if customizing or finishing. The heavier weight of the Astoria might pose logistical challenges, while the Westfield’s included floor simplifies part of the process. Budget for additional costs like paint, shingles, and tools, especially if you want a finished look right away.
Frequently Asked Questions
How difficult is it to assemble these sheds?
Both sheds are designed for DIY assembly, but the Westfield typically requires at least two adults working over a weekend or two, given its 32-hour estimated build time. The Astoria shed, with its pre-cut components and flexible design, can be manageable for experienced DIYers but may be challenging for beginners due to its weight and customization options. Patience and proper planning are key for a smooth build.
Can I customize the appearance of these sheds?
Yes, both sheds are designed to be painted and shingled, allowing you to match your home or landscape. The Astoria shed does not include paint or shingles, so you’ll need to purchase those separately, giving you full control over the aesthetic. The Westfield comes with treated siding ready for your finishing touches, and its built-in features like the window can be customized as well.
Which shed offers better durability?
The Westfield shed is constructed with treated engineered wood siding designed to withstand wind and snow loads, making it more resilient in challenging weather conditions. The Astoria shed, while made from pre-primed wood, may require additional weatherproofing and maintenance over time. For long-term durability, especially in harsh climates, the Westfield is typically the better choice.
Is the included floor sufficient for heavy equipment?
The Westfield’s floor is included and built to handle typical outdoor storage needs, providing a solid base for lawn mowers and tools. The Astoria shed also includes a floor kit, but its heavy weight and large interior space mean you should verify the floor’s load capacity if storing particularly heavy equipment. Proper installation and reinforcement can help ensure safety and longevity.
What additional costs should I expect?
Both sheds require extra purchases for paint, shingles, and possibly tools, which can add several hundred dollars to your overall investment. The Astoria shed’s assembly process might also involve rental equipment or professional help if you lack the manpower. Budgeting for these extras upfront can prevent surprises and ensure you finish your project to your satisfaction.
Conclusion
If you prioritize maximum interior space and customization, the Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed offers a flexible, large-area solution—ideal for DIY enthusiasts prepared for a longer setup process. Conversely, for those seeking a durable, feature-rich shed with built-in amenities and less ongoing maintenance, the Westfield 12×24 is a strong candidate, especially in climates demanding sturdier construction. Your choice depends on whether you prefer raw space and customization or durability and integrated features.
Evergreen bestsellers Picks
bestsellers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
